Photo: Pool / Getty Images News / Getty Images
A Utah judge has ordered the release of a transcript from a previously closed courtroom hearing related to the murder case of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, citing the importance of public access to the judicial process.
State District Judge Tony Graf ruled Monday that transparency is “foundational” to the court system, authorizing the release of a 97-page transcript from an Oct. 24 closed-door hearing. Media organizations, including The Associated Press, had pushed for access, noting the hearing also marked the first time defense attorneys raised the possibility of banning cameras from the courtroom.
Prosecutors have charged Tyler Robinson with aggravated murder in connection with the Sept. 10 shooting death of Kirk on the Utah Valley University campus in Orem. Authorities have said they intend to seek the death penalty. Robinson has not yet entered a plea.
During the October hearing, Robinson’s attorneys argued that images of their client in shackles and jail clothing could unfairly influence potential jurors. Defense attorney Richard Novak suggested banning cameras would be a simple way to reduce visual bias, emphasizing that the case should not be tried in the media. Portions of the transcript and an accompanying audio recording were redacted to protect sensitive security information.
Graf has not ruled on whether cameras will ultimately be banned, but he has imposed restrictions. He previously allowed Robinson to wear civilian clothing during pretrial hearings while requiring restraints for safety reasons, in line with Utah court rules. The judge also barred media outlets from publishing images or footage that reveal Robinson’s restraints.
Earlier this month, Graf temporarily halted a media livestream after it showed the defendant’s shackles and warned that future violations could result in broadcast terminations.
In a separate decision, Graf denied a request by media attorneys to formally intervene in the case, stating they do not need party status to access court records. However, he ordered that news organizations be notified of any future attempts to close hearings or restrict filings.
A preliminary hearing in the case is scheduled to begin May 18, when prosecutors are expected to outline their evidence against Robinson.
SOURCE: WHSV3